College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

Diners' choices affect more than their server

Long-time restaurant employee shares her experiences, gives recommendations to diners

By Joanna Halverson

Mirror Staff Writer

|

Published: Friday, November 13, 2009

Updated: Thursday, November 12, 2009

I have developed an intolerant, sarcastic attitude toward restaurant diners after five years in the business. These are the most annoying harries from diners.

And yes, you can keep the change.

"We'd like to have a booth, if possible." In the restaurant world, that's like saying, "We'd like to have unprotected sex without pregnancy or STDs, if possible." Well, it's possible...but I wouldn't recommend it.

You should know that if there is a booth actually available for your party, I am going to bring you to it first. I know 96 percent of guests prefer to sit in booths. I will only bring you to a table if that is my best option.

But since the final decision is ultimately in your hands, I must warn you that by choosing to disrupt the server rotation, you are causing a lot of problems. The server you have unwittingly rejected has now been skipped. While he or she is grumbling about a empty section, the server you have unknowingly chosen will probably be double or triple-sat.

Therefore, by choosing the booth, you choose a server who is twice as busy as the rest of the staff and will be much less attentive. Fine. If you want to sit in a booth, realize you will probably be waiting twice as long to get drinks.

"We would like a spot with a little privacy." Oh, you would like privacy? Well, that's called eating at home. This? We call this dinner rush.

"We'd like to sit where we can see a TV." Now, it's a rule-of-thumb that any restaurant with "sports bar" in the name has at least one TV visible in every area. At the establishment where I work, the only place you would not be able to see a TV would be in a bathroom stall, and even then you can still hear one.

So, you would like to see a TV? Well, we have TVs in the restrooms - perhaps you would like me to have your meal served to you while you sit on the toilet.

"So, what's good to eat here?" Seriously? Nothing. Nothing is good to eat here. And here's why: Your server watches the kitchen make food. Often, less grease is used in an oil change. You can also assume your server has eaten at the restaurant several times a week for at least the past year.

That said, for your server the food is probably as appealing as mac-and-cheese from home.

"How much to tip?" Here's an answer to the age-old question: A tip should never be less than one gallon of gas, and a tip should always be a minimum of 20 percent, unless your server was blatantly ignoring you.

If it's a busy night, don't dismiss your server as rude. Contrary to popular belief, your server has other things to do. Take all of your needs times the number of tables he or she is juggling.

On a busy night, your server will not have the time to attend to every request you may have every ten seconds. The customer is always the most important, yes, but the customer is not always the most considerate. This is what needs amending.
Of course, if it's a slow night and you can see your server standing around, texting, talking with other employees and rudely ignoring you, then you are exempt from the 20 percent rule.

Different exceptions to the 20 percent rule include tickets that are less than $15. If you order something cheap, maybe a $7 appetizer and water your ticket is $7.50, at most. Here, the 20 percent tip ($1.50) just doesn't cut it. Your server had to work just as hard to bring you a $7 plate as opposed to a $30 plate.

And don't nix the tip if your food was screwed up. I promise – 80 percent of the time it's the kitchen's fault. And the kitchen is paid hourly, mind you. You pay the server. And the server has no control over what the kitchen produces to bring to your table, or how fast that may take.

The golden rule of dining out: If you can't afford to leave a decent tip, you shouldn't be eating out.

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

2 comments

Springs1
Sat Jan 2 2010 15:48
"And don't nix the tip if your food was screwed up. I promise – 80 percent of the time it's the kitchen's fault. And the kitchen is paid hourly, mind you. You pay the server. And the server has no control over what the kitchen produces to bring to your table, or how fast that may take."You are soooooo wrong that 80 percent of the time it's the kitchen staff's fault. You have control over what the kitchen produces by:A. Putting in the order right or wrong(My husband and I have had this happen a few times at least for sure that servers admitted to us they put in the order wrong into the computer.B. You have control of WHAT you bring out to our table. As far as how fast it takes the make, you have to put in the order correctly for certain things to have it come out faster such as let's say I order a medium rare steak. You press the button "Medium Well", well that is YOUR FAULT you put in the order wrong as to WHY I waited LONGER to get my food. It takes longer to cook meat more, DUH.You have to also put in the order as quickly as you possibly can by doing it in a fair manner(meaning don't put my order into the computer if you have someone's food order that is ready, because they ordered BEFORE I just did). In other words, don't go to 2 other tables to ask them if they need anything before putting in my order or buss a table, because those can be done right after. How long you wait to put in my order COUNTS A LOT. Also, we have servers that have forgotten to put in orders as well. We have had that happen 3 times to us.I would say 95% of the time it's the server's fault that your food is wrong. For example, undercooked chicken or a pickle under a bun or hair in the food are things the server couldn't possibly control. Things the can control are most things that you don't have to touch the food to notice the mistake. If it's another server bringing out the food that didn't take the order, the containers or bottles of condiments COULD have been brought out by the original server that took the order and prevented such VERY PREVENTABLE mistakes like that. If it's a mistake that another server brought out such as a wrong side dish or missing side dish for example, while it's not my server's fault, that other server was in the SERVICE, therefore, the tip WILL and SHOULD be altered. You have LOTS of control over what the kitchen produces. Putting in the order right or wrong is HUGE. Bringing out food that is wrong is also something such as if I order extra crispy bacon that isn't covered up by anything, you can tell just by simply LOOKING at bacon if it's crispy or not. While my or another server didn't cook the bacon, use your common sense when SERVING the food. It's not rocket science. It's MOST of the time, the server's fault when things go wrong with your food. THAT IS THE GOD'S TRUTH!! QUIT SPEWING THESE LIES!! "Different exceptions to the 20 percent rule include tickets that are less than $15. If you order something cheap, maybe a $7 appetizer and water your ticket is $7.50, at most. Here, the 20 percent tip ($1.50) just doesn't cut it. Your server had to work just as hard to bring you a $7 plate as opposed to a $30 plate."I would say a $7 check with a water would be at the MOST a $2 tip unless I had exceptional service. Actually, sometimes a $7 dish is harder to bring out such as I ask for extra condiments like ranch with appetizers a lot. A $30 plate may be harder or not as hard, depending on what the food is. My burger orders are nightmares to servers with adding mayo, mustard, ranch, and bbq sauce or tartar sauce on the side with ordering fries with no salt and burger with only lettuce and extra onions. I don't agree that you worked "JUST AS HARD", in fact, sometimes you work harder for a cheaper meal.Let's say you didn't have any modifications with either the $7 appetizer or the $30 plate, WHY should we not tip the same? I can see if something is like just $5, at least leave a dollar, but do you really expect $5 on a $7 check? You are nuts if you do. I don't see anything wrong with tipping $1.50 on a $7 check. WHY should tipping rules change just because the amount is different? It's one thing if 20% isn't even a dollar worth, but if it's over a dollar, you should get the percentage that it comes up to as far as how the service was."a tip should always be a minimum of 20 percent, unless your server was blatantly ignoring you."NO, if my server gets my order wrong, HECK NO!! Our server overcharges us, HECK NO!! If our server forgets things, HECK NO!! If our server doesn't apologize for their mistake or mistakes, OF COURSE NOT!! If our server is unfair by handing out things in the wrong order on a tray, NO WAY will they get much a tip for being rude.You act like we OWE you instead of EARNING YOUR TIP!! It's not the kitchen staff's fault if you are our server that brought us wrong food. COMPARE THE WRITTEN ORDERS TO THE FOOD. Make sure I have my ranch I asked for. If not, say you are...
Your name
Fri Nov 13 2009 13:40
Wow. Someone needs to quit their job or at least take a few deep breaths and see things from the customer's perspective. They don't know and don't have to know what goes on behind the scenes--it's your job to make it seamless and effortless. This means that yeah, your restaurant gets busy--that's why they hired you. So step up your game and slap on a smile and make things run smoothly. I get frustrated trying to serve people and juggle all of their needs and other staff being bitchy and the kitchen messing up, but I don't blame that on the customer. They're paying (overpaying, really) to eat at mediocre restaurant; they get to request to sit wherever the hell they want, server rotation be damned. They're guidelines, not rules, and that server can suck it up. I know, I am one, and I've been a hostess. This article is really pathetic and sad even though it clearly was supposed to be hip and snarky.






log out